I kind of fell off the
Historical Sew Monthly wagon there for a few months. It was sort of on purpose, as I didn't really have any projects in October that were appropriate, and my Silver Screen project just wasn't going to get done during November with everything that is going on. I'm probably never going to finish it, actually. That's okay. This year has been instructive as to what is practical for me as far as sewing time is concerned, and I'm learning to be more focused about sewing purchases and projects.

That said, this dress was pure frivolity. I bought the fabric way back in April, intending to make a 1930s dress with it for the brown challenge in September. (It is hard to tell in the photos, but the predominant color in the print is brown). I wanted to copy
Jill's original 1930s dress in this fabric with a contrasting green collar. I had sketched the collar shape a few times, and thought I could swing it. I thought the fabric read Art Deco, and I really liked the fall palette. After making the
1934 McCall's 8272, I was pretty confident about how to draft and construct the collar detail, and I knew I could use my Frankenpattern to get the basic shape of the original.

In the intervening months, however, I sort of fell out of love with the fabric, and lost interest in the project. I was concerned that the colorway didn't work for my complexion, and didn't want to spend time or precious energy on a project that wouldn't look good on me. I was sorting out my fabric bin earlier this month, and ran across the fabric again, and decided to put it in a donation pile. I resolved to let it go, but decided at the last minute to just make it up already.
I regretted the decision almost the instant I made it, and spent a day or two trying to talk myself out of it, and second-guessed every minute of the making. I thought my drafted collar looked wrong, I didn't like the contrast, I thought the tab detail on the pockets was overkill, I didn't want to top stitch anything, I didn't like the fabric, I couldn't believe I was "wasting" a morning that I actually felt okay on a dress to wear for Thanksgiving when I could be working on the projects in my winter sewing pile.

Sometimes you just have to plough through to the end. I'm actually glad I finished this dress! It was exactly the right thing to wear for Thanksgiving day, and I'm actually really happy with the end result. It isn't an exact copy of the original, but it definitely works for the era. The vintage buttons came from the McCall's 8272, which I took apart at the end of the summer. It wasn't really a great dress for me for a variety of reasons, and I couldn't see that I would wear it again next year. The fabric wasn't very breathable, and I wasn't happy with the way it was wearing after only a couple wears. But the buttons were fabulous, so I saved those!!

I drafted the collar on the fly, and then just attached it like a flat collar after top stitching it down. It was very easy to construct, actually. I probably could have stood to make the sleeve cuffs wider to match the width of the collar, but by the time I realized my mistake, I had been fighting with the cuffs for a while and was about ready to chuck them all together. The pocket tabs were easy-peasy and while they didn't feature on
the original dress, I've seen the detail on enough period patterns and extant dresses to feel confident that they would fit.
Because my energy levels have been extremely bad these last months, I confess that I ran out of steam when it came time to make the self-belt. I had it all cut out, but then I just.couldn't.do it. I ran a bit of elastic through the waist casing and called it a day. It's not really period appropriate, but it was very comfortable. And the dress is just for me anyway, so I'm not super concerned.
I also made a pair of coordinating gauntlets out of some copper colored Swish yarn. They warmed things up considerably! (The gauntlets are just a general item in my wardrobe--I didn't make them specifically for this dress, it was a happy coincidence)
I used the same waffle stitch pattern I used last winter on the
lava gauntlets, but made them a bit longer, and added some stitches to the end to make them wider at the elbow end and narrower toward the wrist. I also seamed them to leave a thumb hole, which I like quite a bit.
I'm pretty happy with my top-stitching on this project--it's not perfect, but I get a little better on each try!
The contrasting fabric is from Michael Miller and makes me think I might use some more in a different color way to make a solid colored dress at some point--it is very nice soft fabric.
I like this mitt pattern because it has just enough going on to keep the knitting interesting, but not so much that I can't have my mind on a program or something else at the same time. And I adore Swish yarn! I think it is my favorite yarn so far.
The seam is a lot better looking in person than on this photo--it is quite straight and neat.
And my boots are all wrong for a period photo (as is my hair) but as I said: poor energy, and it was Thanksgiving, after all!
The Challenge: Redo (Brown)
Pattern: self-drafted/Frankenpatterned
Year: ~1934
Notions: bias tape, all purpose zip, vintage resin buttons, thread
How historically accurate is it? 6/10. The basic shape is good, and a reasonable facsimile of the original dress, but the zip is wrong for the period (zips were in use, but not commonly available to home sewers until later). Press studs or buttons would have been better for a side closure. The bias tape I used is modern, although the usage is period (although, probably for a dress like this, it would have had proper facings). The 100% cotton fabric is reasonable, as is the print. The original dress had a gored skirt, but I prefer a simpler cut. It's not wrong for the period, but gores would have given it a more period look. The cut-on sleeves are period appropriate, but the original dress had set-in sleeves. The elasticized waist is wrong. I went for cut-on because I strongly dislike how inset sleeves fit me on woven fabrics. I should have gone with the fabric self-belt and in-set sleeves for better accuracy, but I was going for comfort and wearability over strict period accuracy.
Hours to complete: 4-5. The collar and cuffs added a lot of extra time.
First worn: November 26, 2015 for Thanksgiving Day
Total cost: ~$40