Another day, another dress. I'm calling this one the Celtic Knot dress. I'm super original like that. (When I was a child, my dolls all had super original names like "Special Dolly" or "Grandma Ropps Dolly"; I figure it's not worth fighting the impulse at this late stage)

I have a
ready-to-wear dress from a few years ago that is quite similar in style to this one, and I wear it quite a bit in the summer, so I thought this pattern would be a good one to try. I'm still not sure about this dress, however--the pattern has some issues and I did some dumb things during construction, but at least it (mostly) fits. The fabric was inexpensive, so I don't mind considering this a wearable muslin (because it is wearable), but I don't think it is going to be my TNT dress pattern. There are some fitting issues, and while I didn't mind working 9 buttonholes by hand, there were a lot of fiddly bits to this dress. I'm also perplexed as to why this dress *just* fits--the sizing on the envelope would indicate that it should be too big all over (and I've made this vintage size before and it was too big) It's a good job I didn't grade it down at all.

The first problem is that the bodice doesn't begin to fit on the skirt section with the waist shaping as indicated on the pattern. I had to pleat the skirt 5" to make it fit, and then realized there was no way it was going to fit around me, so I pulled out all the pleats and tucks and just attached it straight (this after finishing the waist band with seam binding--oy!) When I fixed that, I realized there was no shaping in the bodice at all, so I threw some pleats in under the bust. After I wore it for a few hours yesterday morning, I realized a) I couldn't breathe or move and b) the pleats just looked weird, so I took them out and redid all the photos. I have to say, the fit is a lot better now. Breathing is good.

I should add that I tried on the dress with almost every stage of the project, but sometimes it is hard to see how it is going to finish until you actually get there. I finished the whole dress, buttons and all, and realized that the bodice was at least 2" too long and there was a ton of fabric pooling in the small of my back. As in, it looked like a drop waist on me.
I know I'm short-waisted, but really. It was too much. After pulling out the seam binding and reattaching the bodice twice, I wasn't in a hurry to repeat the experience, so I just pinned up the bodice and sewed a seam right along the original one. So now there is a bit of extra bulk along the waist that I don't love but at least it sits at my waist now. Fortunately, this fabric is fairly thin, so it can take a little bit of bulk here and there. It is quilt-weight cotton, but it has a nice hand and drape, and is much thinner than some of the quilting cottons I work with.
I used vintage green seam binding to finish the sleeves and hem, although the skirt ended up too long (again!) so I just turned it over once more and blind stitched it. So it looks like a 2 1/2" hem, but is really closer to five. It is neat, though! I ended up cheating the seam allowance on the sleeves because I could tell they were going to finish too small, and as it is, they just fit.

I do like how the sleeves are constructed, and I love that shoulder dart, which I probably should have deepened just a smidge as the shoulders want to slide around a bit on my narrowness. There was something goofy in the pattern instructions about reinforcing the underarm area, and there was an extra pattern piece that didn't fit where the pattern said it should. It is possible that the extra piece would have made the bodice fit better with the pleats, but it was at least 3" longer than the bodice, and I could not work out how to fit it into the side seams so I left it off. It appeared to me that the piece (which was rectangular) was just supposed to lay over the side seams as reinforcement on the inside, but maybe it was supposed to widen the bodice under the arms instead. So at least some of the fitting issues might be due to that.

And these buttons! I found them from an etsy seller in a set of ten, and I knew they were the perfect complement to this fabric. The design is similar to the celtic knots in the fabric.

My dummy mistake was not using interfacing on the facing section of the bodice. I really need to pony up and get proper interfacing, as the pellon fusible I've been using for most of my projects doesn't always hold up well. I find interfacing so pesky. Sometimes I use it and sometimes I don't, but this is the first time I really should have and didn't. I should also state for the record that I'm very grateful that this pattern had a shaped facing pattern piece, so that I didn't have to draft one (my previous experience with drafting shaped facings has not gone particularly well). I really like the unusual shape of the neckline. I did opt for straight sleeves instead of the notched version that went with this neckline, in part because my experience with notched sleeves is that they curl with wearing, and also because I just didn't want to mess with it.

I put my selvages to good use on this dress (having examined the insides of my RTW dress that was similar) and lined up the folded over edges of the button band on both sections of the dress along the selvages. I did not attempt any pattern matching, but even though it is directional, I think the design is subtle enough not to need it. I left off the inseam pockets because they were tiny and in a weird place on the skirt, and I have in mind to add patch pockets at some point.
That said, I like the fabric and the color very much, and I do think I'll wear it. I have a green belt that coordinates fairly well, but I think I like the black for contrast.
Celtic Knot Dress: Simplicity 4260 (from 1953)
Earrings: from gram
Shoes: Softspots via ebay
Belt: H&M (old)