I wish I could make sound effects on this blog post, because it would start out with a downward chime something like: wah, wah, wah. (Even writing that out looks weird).
I've had in mind to make up the Simplicity 1887 skirt for at least a year, largely on the strength of Masha's makes. I had such good luck with M7353, also on her recommendation, that I thought this would be a good pattern for me. It seemed reminiscent of my beloved Everyday Skirt pattern, but slimmer through the body, so I thought it was worth a shot.
*cue the ominous music* I had in mind to cut my Folk Birds dress down to a skirt since the fall at least, but have been putting it off for a variety of reasons. This week I decided to be brave, cut into my dress, and hope for the best. I also decided that I was going to be okay if it turned out badly.
I should say first that these photos make the skirt look better than it really is. The pattern is bananas. There are some nice things about it--the deep yoked pockets, the shape of the skirt, and the surprisingly flattering pleats in the front. But the waistband construction is completely bonkers, and the elastic application more so. It was my first time making a shaped waistband, however, so the experience wasn't totally wasted.
First, my mods: Masha recommended sizing down to a 16, since our lower measurements are similar and she found a 16 worked well for her (I DM'd her on Instagram to ask for advice before cutting), and I think that was exactly right. I added 2.5" to the skirt length because the drafted length would have been mid-thigh on me.
I also lined it with some leftover bemberg from the stash, which added some construction complication to the already bonkers waistband. I was expecting this to work like the Everyday skirt, which is clever and easy to put together. Not so much. My first mistake was not having enough fabric for the facing on the waistband, so I used lining instead (I interlined the waistband with some medium weight cotton for stability). The inner lining makes the waistband slippery and was a pain in the neck to top stitch neatly. After ripping out the stitches three or four times, I gave up. Let's just say it's not my best work and don't look too closely at the details.
The skirt also doesn't want to sit at my natural waist, so I feel like it is falling down every five minutes. I realize it is drafted to sit 1" below the natural waist, but this is not flattering on me, and I was hoping that by snugging the elastic, it would sit higher. Nope. Also: the elastic guides are completely wrong. I used 4" less on each to start with and still cut off 3" at the end. I probably should have used braided elastic instead of knit, since I think that is part of the fit problem--the knit elastic isn't "firm" enough to stay put.
Honestly, I think I could achieve the same look with the Everyday skirt by taking out the side panels (I have actually. I made two skirts this way last winter, although I don't like either of them and they are in the naughty pile waiting to be remade into something else). I like everything about this skirt except the waistband and where it sits on me, but that waistband is super irritating, so I know I won't enjoy wearing it. Blerg.
I almost didn't want to show these photos, but I think it is useful to show what doesn't work as well as what does. Part of me wants to purchase the fabric again and have another go with a different pattern, but I'm not sure I have it in me. My sew-jo is seriously missing in action, and this skirt was not particularly fun to make. I have a knit dress cut out to try as soon as I have coordinating thread, but I'm not that excited about it. Part of it is that it is still quite cold here, and I really don't have a lot of options to keep myself warm except for wool maxi skirt+wool sweater combination. It's okay, but I confess that I'm bored of it, after three months.
Update: I unpicked the whole waistband and facing and removed the wonkus elastic. I redid the top stitching and did the waistband construction just like an Everyday Skirt, which brought the elastic bit more to the back of the skirt (instead of having a weird bulge right to the front of my hips where I do not need bulk!) and also used braided elastic which is much firmer. I'm so much happier with the fit now! The skirt is great, and I'll be happy to wear it! It isn't worth retaking the photos since the fit issues are subtle and don't show up in photos, but take my word for it.
Update # 2: Nope, not a success. I wore it for a day after I redid the elastics and I was literally pulling the skirt up every five minutes. Drove me nuts. So while I think it is flattering and (mostly) comfortable, the skirt is just not going to work for me. But at least it looks nice inside and out now, and I'm happy to pass it along to someone else who it will suit better.
















